Lie Out of Loyalty? It's OK, Say Some

We all know President Trump prizes loyalty (to him) above all else.

 But where does lying come in?  And can it beat honesty when it comes to loyalty?  I guess we should know.  We've seen it play out time and again with this president.

 According to a new study, some people think lying can be ethical.  And they're not all in the cabinet. .

A new Cornell University study shows people who are dishonest out of loyalty feel they are acting ethically and morally but outsiders disagree, seeing those actions as immoral and wrong – unless they lie out of loyalty, newswise.com reports.
Researchers from the Samuel Curtis Johnson Graduate School of Management, was interested in what happens when loyalty clashes with values like honesty and fairness. 

Study lead Angus Hildreth, assistant professor of management and organizations at the school, and his co-author, Cameron Anderson of the University of California, Berkley, worked with nearly 1,400 participants over the course of four studies.

The researchers asked a group of online study participants to read about an actor who took part in a study. Some were told he had signed a pledge of loyalty to a group; others were told he signed a pledge to be fair or simply promised to complete the study. Some participants were told the actor had misrepresented his scores on several tasks, which benefited his group; others were told he had reported his scores honestly. The participants then answered questions about whether the actor behaved ethically.

A different group of participants was placed in those exact scenarios in real life and given the chance to lie to benefit their group. Participants were then asked to judge the ethics of their own behavior.

The researchers found when people were called to be loyal, their moral views of deceit and honesty flipped. Loyal liars viewed their deceit as ethical, even though their actions harmed others. And disloyal truth-tellers viewed their behavior as less ethical, despite acting honestly. Independent judges viewed loyal lies differently, and as less ethical than honesty.

“When loyalties apply – when you’re surrounded by your family, organization or political party – those loyalties influence the way you judge your behavior,” Hildreth says. “You might be doing something harmful to others. But that doesn’t matter to you, because you feel you’re fulfilling a higher value: your loyal duty.”




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

It's OK to Not Be OK

Everyone gets a little rain in their lives, at some point.  I survived breast cancer, my husband was recently treated for colon cancer (not to mention the aneurysm he has on his aorta and leg, which must be surgically removed) and his recently-acquired rheumatoid arthritis.  We have no relationship with either of our families and our son is growing up (with older parents) pretty much just with us.  I live in fear that we will both be gone when he is still too young to manage on his own (he's 17). But people have other disappointments, too -- losing a job, or a loved one, the failure of a relationship. But a new study says that how you respond to adversity can affect how you get through it, according to newswise.com.   Research on how adults deal with adversity has been dominated by studies claiming the most common response is uninterrupted and stable psychological functioning. In other words, this research suggests that most adults are essentially unfazed by major life even
Read more

Want More Productive Employees? Be Nice

Who knew?  Being nice to your employees can really help your bottom line. According to a new study, it pays to be nice to your employees, newswise.com reports.  Showing discipline with kindness, compassion to employees results in better job performance, the web site adds. New research from Binghamton University, State University at New York   finds that showing compassion to subordinates almost always pays off, especially when combined with the enforcement of clear goals and benchmarks. “Being benevolent is important because it can change the perception your followers have of you,” says Chou-Yu Tsai, an assistant professor of management at Binghamton University’s School of Management. “If you feel that your leader or boss actually cares about you, you may feel more serious about the work you do for them.” Tsai and his fellow researchers wanted to determine how both the presence and lack of benevolence affects the job performance of followers. Tsai partnered with Bingham
Read more

Cheat on a Personality Test? People Do, But Not For Much Longer

I don't know how many times you have to take a personality test but did you know they're making it harder to cheat? The test is faster -- and harder to track, according to newswise.com. Psychology researchers have developed a new personality test that is both faster to take and much harder to manipulate by those attempting to control the outcome. “The test draws on the ‘Big Five’ approach to personality assessment, so it’s a new method for personality testing, rather than a new paradigm,” says Adam Meade, a professor of psychology at North Carolina State University and lead author of a paper on the work. “But whether the testing is being done as part of workplace training or for research purposes, there is real value in being able to conduct the test quickly and in making it difficult for users to game the system.” The Big Five theory of personality  focuses on five broad factors: extraversion, conscientiousness, openness, neuroticism and agreeableness. “We used t
Read more